Sunday, June 29, 2008

Campaign 2008

Last week we provided you with a summary of the housing and community development proposals offered by Sen. Barack Obama (D-IL) the presumptive Democratic nominee for President. We planned to provide you with a summary of similar proposals offered by Obama’s opponent, Sen. John McCain (R0AZ), the presumptive Republican nominee for President. Unfortunately we could not get information in time for this edition. The McCain campaign has no information on his housing and community development recommendations on its web site nor could we find comparable information on his web site in the Senate. Calls made to members of his campaign and personal staffs were not returned. A View from D. C. will continue to investigate this matter and will report to you our findings as it becomes available.

We have; however, been scouring the countryside to gather information about the individuals under consideration for the position of vice president and their views and/or actions on housing and community development actions. As the information becomes available, we will share it with you. Thanks to our friends at the Massachusetts Chapter of the National Association of Housing and Redevelopment Officials (MASSNAHRO), we were able to learn about the man considered to be the favorite to be McCain’s running mate, former Massachusetts Governor Mitt Romney.

Romney was Governor of Massachusetts for four years from 2003 to 2007. He decided not to seek reelection when he decided to run for president on the Republican ticket. According to MASSNAHRO, he was not a friend of affordable housing. Here are some actions he undertook:

  • In January 2003, he cut the Affordable Housing Trust Fun by $7.5 million (a 38% cut) as part of his emergency cuts and eliminated the program from the state’s operating budget. The program was moved to the state’s capital budget, but no longer has a guaranteed revenue source to ensure its annual funding.
  • In FY ’05, the Governor vetoed the extension of the state low income housing tax credit program, which has been used to produce new housing for low income households. The Legislature ultimately overrode the Governor’s veto and the program was extended for five years.
  • The Governor’s smart growth criteria failed to recognize the need for affordable housing in suburban and rural areas such as Cape Cod, Central Massachusetts, and Western Massachusetts. The Governor’s smart growth criteria has made it much more difficult to obtain state approval and funding for new affordable housing because available sites in these communities are not located near public transit or in town centers.
  • The Governor eliminated funding for the Capital Improvement and Preservation Fund. Since 1999 the programs has helped to preserve more than 2,600 low income housing units which were at-risk of being converted to market rate housing. The Executive Office of Administration and Finance (A&F) also said it no longer wanted to use state or Federal funds to preserve existing privately-owned housing which is currently used by tenants. A&F also floated a proposal to begin “selling off” state public housing to residents although no legislation was filed.
  • The Governor cut funding for the Public Housing Modernization Program from $61.3 million in the FY2003 capital budget to $50.45 million in FY2005, an 18 percent cut. He also cut $5 million from the public housing operating subsidy as part of his emergency cuts in the FY03 budget and under funded the program in his budgets for FY04 and FY05 by as much as $10 million each year.
  • In his FY 05 budget, the Governor proposed raising rents for families in state public housing from 30% of income to 38% of income for rent. The Legislature ultimately approved a smaller rent increase to 32%.
  • In FY 04 the Governor eliminated the Rent Escrow Program which matched savings accumulated by public housing tenants for the purchase of a new home, education, or work training.
  • The Governor cut the Alternative Housing Voucher Program for people with disabilities from $3 million in FY03 to $2.3 million in FY04 and FY05.
  • The Governor cut the Massachusetts Rental Voucher Program (MRVP) from $26.6 million in FY03 to $22.6 million in FY04. The Legislature modestly increased MRVP to $24.2 million in FY05, but no new vouchers were issued.
  • In the FY05 budget, the Governor eliminated funding for the Individual Self-Sufficiency Program, which provided housing assistance for homeless individuals.
  • In the FY06 budget, the Governor proposed a three-year limit and strict work requirements for 4,500 households receiving MRVP assistance. As a result, thousands of low income tenants with average incomes of approximately $15,000 would be displaced and the tenant-based voucher program would cease to exist in three years. The Legislature rejected this proposal.
  • In the FY06 budget, the Governor vetoed much-needed funding increases of $2 million for the Massachusetts Rental Voucher Program (MRVP) and $2 million for the Residential Assistance for Families in transition (RAFT) Program. The Legislature overrode these vetoes.

Source: Massachusetts NAHRO


Q&A with Sheila Crowley, President of the National Low Income Housing Coalition


Sheila Crowley is President and CEO of the National Low Income Housing Coalition (NLIHC). NLHIC is dedicated solely to ending America's affordable housing crisis (www.nlihc.org). NLIHC believes this is achievable because it is a problem which Americans are capable of solving. While NLIHC is concerned about the housing circumstances of all low income people, it focuses its advocacy on those with the most serious housing problems, the lowest income households.

Sheila joined the staff of the National Low Income Housing Coalition in December 1998, after two decades in Richmond, Virginia in organizational leadership, direct service, policy advocacy, and scholarship. She is a social worker with a bachelor’s (1976), master’s (1978), and Ph.D. (1998) from the School of Social Work at Virginia Commonwealth University. She has worked in staff, board, and consulting roles with organizations that focus on family housing, AIDS housing, senior housing, housing for people with disabilities, and homeless services. She is an adjunct faculty member for the VCU School of Social Work and for George Mason University Department of Social Work, teaching social policy, social justice, policy advocacy, and community and organizational practice. NLIHC has been the lead organization pursuing a national housing trust fund which is included in the mortgage relief bill under negotiation in the Congress.

1. Congress is negotiating a housing bill which includes the creation of a housing trust fund. What are some of the key elements to the trust fund which will benefit low income families?

The basic premise of the trust fund is that part of the population is left out of the housing production mix, namely the extremely low income household. We need to expand the supply of affordable housing for this population and be able to add a variety of new resources into the production mix. The trust fund will be treated as a direct grant so that some portion of the apartments being built will be for the extremely low-income population.

2. NLIHC was at the forefront in the effort to secure passage of the housing trust fund. What was the difference in getting the trust fund passed now versus three or four years ago?

The key was the change in leadership with the Democratic Congress and the change in leadership on the Financial Services Committee. Rep. Barney Frank (D-MA) said he would place this at the top of his agenda. There was a window of opportunity created by the foreclosure crisis and subsequent legislation. We had a feeling we had a chance to insert the trust fund bill into the larger foreclosure bill. We were able to stick to it because our funders stuck with us. They continued to stick with the housing trust fund campaign so when we needed people to act we had thousands who knew what we were talking about and could act quickly on our behalf.

3. Affordable housing programs, particularly public housing, have seen their funding levels reduced over the last eight years. Will these funds compete with existing housing programs for funding?

The trust fund was designed specifically to be outside of the appropriations process so it doesn’t compete with the other programs.

4. What can be done to bring in private sector dollars to compensate for the losses in public housing dollars?

That is a tough one because I believe public housing is at a crossroads. It has been battered about badly by the Bush Administration, starved without resources, its stock is aging; there is no investment in new stock or in adequately maintaining the current stock. We need to think about what public housing will look like in 50 years versus the next five years. It is a hard conversation to have in the middle of the struggle with the diminishing resources and in some communities, particularly the smaller ones, good stock. What do we do to keep the stock in good condition and what do we do to replace what has been lost. We have to figure out what to do with the stock which is past its useful life. It is a very hard conversation to have when you are immersed in it with the tenants who have public housing as their lifeline, and workers who built a career in the field. It can be hard to see the forest through the trees.

5. Your organization represents a large number of tenants and community housing activists; whereas, groups such as CLPHA, PHADA and NAHRO represent housing providers. Oftentimes both parties are at odds on issues. What can be done to bridge the differences between these parties?

I am not sure how to answer that. With a new administration a lot of people want to reconsider the Department of Housing and Urban Development (HUD) as an entity. HUD has been left wit poor leadership and a demoralized staff. What is the next step in the reconsideration of HUD? This view will look at the quality of person leading HUD the different sectors and departments at HUD. We need to think of the future of the agency and the program departments. Right now it is too silo oriented. There are different departments controlling the Federal housing stock and the Federal assisted stock with common problems but no discussions between them.

Interesting reads

This is an article which appeared in the New York Times which discusses how the mortgage crisis continues to snowball.

"As Housing Bill Evolves, Crisis Grows Deeper" by by Vikas Bajaj


This is an article in the Boston Globe which points out that assisted housing in Sen. Barack Obama’s former state Senate district is in bad shape.

"Grim proving ground for Obama's housing policy" by by Binyamin Applebaum

Monday, June 23, 2008

Obama Presidency Would Fully Fund CDBG and Restore Operating Subsidies

If elected president, Democratic nominee Sen. Barack Obama (D-IL) promises to fully fund the Community Development Block Grant (CDBG) program and restore public housing operating subsidies to their “original purpose” as part of a comprehensive Urban Policy Agenda. Obama is calling for an urban policy which calls for a stronger Federal commitment to cities by stimulating economic growth, increasing the supply and availability of affordable housing, improving safety within cities, and addressing urban poverty.

If elected, Obama promises to:

- Create a White House Office of Urban Policy with a director appointed to coordinate all federal urban programs. The director will report directly to the president.

- Increase the production of affordable housing by creating an affordable housing trust fund and reforming the Federal Housing Administration (FHA). (Legislation is currently working its way through Congress which creates a trust fund and to make revisions to the FHA. Obama supports the legislation);

- Provide an additional $10 billion in additional authority for mortgage revenue bonds (MRB). MRBs are tax-exempt bonds that state and local governments issue through housing finance agencies (HFAs) to help fund below-market-interest-rate mortgages for first-time qualifying homebuyers. Eligible borrowers are first-time homebuyers with low to moderate incomes below 115 percent of median family income.

- Provide a ten percent universal mortgage tax credit for up to 10 million middle-class homeowners who do not itemize their taxes and thus do not receive a mortgage interest tax deduction.

- Ensure funding is provided for any mandates imposed by the Federal government.

- Increase funding for business development and infrastructure improvement;

- Create a National infrastructure Reinvestment Bank to enhance Federal transportation efforts;

- Create 20 Promise Neighborhoods where comprehensive services are available to address deeply entrenched concentrations of poverty; and,

- Create a prisoner-to-work program modeled after the welfare-to-work program to assist ex-offenders find employment after their release from prison.

For a comprehensive list of the initiatives proposed by the senator go to http://www.barackobama.com/issues/urbanpolicy/.

Analysis

The senator is proposing an ambitious urban agenda which, in addition to be very costly, raises almost as many questions as the issues it attempts to solve. The most important component of this agenda is simply this: he is placing a priority on urban America. That can not be underestimated in seeing some of these initiatives brought to fruition.

The creation of a White House Office of Urban Policy, designed to “coordinate all federal urban programs” with its director reporting to the president seems to diminish the role of the Secretary of Housing and Urban Development (HUD). How the two offices coordinate will be critical to the success of these urban initiatives. In the Washington, DC world of politics one has to assume the office in the White House, the seat closest to the president, will have greater authority. The office is also expected to ensure federal dollars are spent on the “highest-impact programs”. It is unclear if this means deeper targeting in some programs or performance-based funding.

Obama’s initiatives are clearly focused on the low and very-low income households. It is not unreasonable for supporters of programs such as CDBG and HOME to brace for efforts to secure deeper targeting of those funds. In calling for full funding for the CDBG program, he hopes to restores cuts to the public housing operating subsidies but does not specify to what levels. There is nothing in his document which stipulates fully funding operating subsidies. It is also unclear how HUD programs will be restored to their “original purposes”.

The creation of a housing trust fund and a new FHA are likely to occur before the close of the current legislative calendar. While an increase in MRB authority would be welcomed, it is unfortunate his agenda does not call for an increase in low-income tax credits. An increase in tax-credits would spur additional production and provide housing relief for working families.

While it is encouraging that Senator Obama is creating an urban vision for the country, there are significant hurdles to overcome. The relationship between the White House Office on Urban Policy and HUD could be too traumatic for its own good. The same holds true for the Departments of Transportation, Commerce, etc. Personally, I think establishing the White House office is a mistake. It makes more sense to provide HUD with greater resources and flexibility to allow communities to meet the needs of their community. While Obama’s rhetoric will sound encouraging to those in the housing and community development field. The reality and experience suggests there may be some improvements but not enough to over turn the damages done due to reduced funding and lack of flexibility over the last eight years. It is also important to note: Obama is not planning to increase funding to these urban initiatives. He recently delivered a speech to the United States Conference of Mayors in which he indicated that while he will be a friend to them, not to expect additional revenue. The revenue must come from "the bottom up".

(Next week a look at Republican nominee Sen. John McCain’s housing policy.)

Q&A with Conrad Egan, President and Chief Executive Officer of the National Housing Conference (NHC)

Conrad Egan is the President and Chief Executive Officer of the National Housing Conference (NHC). Mr. Egan is the President of the National Housing Conference. He served the United States Department of Housing and Urban Development (HUD) as Director of the Office of Multifamily Housing Management and later as Special Assistant to the Secretary of HUD. He served as Executive Vice President of NHP Inc., one of the Nation’s largest multifamily property owners and managers. He also served as the Executive Director of the Millennial Housing Commission. He is currently serving as Chairman of the Fairfax County Redevelopment and Housing Authority, and on the Boards of the Community Preservation and Development Corporation and the Open Door Housing Fund. For more than 75 years, the nonprofit NHC has been the United Voice for Housing (www.nhc.org). A membership drawn from every industry segment forms the foundation for NHC’s broad, nonpartisan advocacy for national policies and legislation that promote suitable housing in a safe, decent environment. NHC's research affiliate, the Center for Housing Policy, specializes in developing solutions through research. In partnership with NHC and its members, the Center works to broaden understanding of the nation’s housing challenges and to examine the impact of policies and programs developed to address these needs.

1. What do you think is the biggest challenge facing the housing community today?

To become relevant, once again, by connecting more to the middle class housing challenges while maintaining our commitment to lower income households and by reinventing our strategies to connect with the increasing creativity and political will at the state and local levels. We can achieve this by moving to an incentive and performance-based system which rewards state and local leadership and by joining with transportation, jobs and energy conservation strategies and opportunities.

2. Your organization has conducted a significant amount of research on the housing crisis facing working families. What must be done to ensure these families have decent, safe and affordable housing?

We need to significantly increase the availability of sites and other opportunities which increase the supply of workforce homes by better utilizing underutilized sites, fostering inclusionary zoning and reducing regulatory barriers.

3. As Congress seeks to reach an agreement on a housing bill to address the mortgage crisis, which provisions in the legislations under debate hold the most promise for affordable housing?

The legislation will provide funds to help stabilize impacted neighborhoods and retooling of the Federal financing tools to encourage and support broad-based loan and restructuring for challenged borrowers.

4. You participated in a retreat designed to develop a public housing agenda for the new administration, what is your reaction to the discussions at that meeting?

We need to increase the momentum to convert the public housing system from an abusive parent-child relationship to a contractual relationship between consenting adults. We need to couple this with connecting the public housing inventory to the world of real estate by attracting debt and equity capital from the investment markets through a transformative move to property/collateral based financing with a conclusive commitment to completely eliminate the capital backlog.

5. As you peer into your crystal ball, what does the future hold for affordable housing as we know it today? Will it change? If so, in what way? Will it stay the same? If so why?

The challenge of meeting the housing needs of extreme/very low income households will become harder as the budget noose tightens. But we must remain heroically committed to the goal. Opportunities to connect housing with transportation and climate challenges initiatives will increase and we must be strongly involved in those efforts. There will be more emphasis on improving the government sponsored enterprises (GSEs) and Federal Housing Administration (FHA) support of affordable housing through updated financing techniques and products. (GSEs are a group of financial services corporations created by the United States Congress. Their function is to enhance the flow of credit to targeted sectors of the economy and to make those segments of the capital markets more efficient and transparent. The Community Reinvestment Act (see June 11 posting) will be strengthened, expanded and updated. The national, state and local leadership will increasingly support good affordable homes for all Americans. The business community will recognize the importance of affordable homes and will become more involved.

Interesting Reads

Here is an article in the June 21, 2008 edition of The Washington Post which discusses the difficulty the budget situation will present to the new president.

http://www.washingtonpost.com/wp-dyn/content/article/2008/06/20/AR2008062002889.html?hpid=topnews

Here is a link to a recent three part series in The Washington Post on the credit crisis.

http://www.washingtonpost.com/wp-srv/business/creditcrisis/

Here is an article in the latest edition of New Yorker Magazine on what Sen. Hillary Rodham Clinton (D-NY) won by losing the Democratic nomination.

http://nymag.com/news/politics/47837/

Sunday, June 15, 2008

Happy Father's Day

Happy Father's Day to all of the men who have demonstrated what love, hard work, and patience can mean to a family. May you and your love ones be blessed. For those unable to share this day with their dads, don't dwell on the time lost but remember the times you had. Hopefully they bring you loving memories.

Washington Post article on the foreclosure crisis

The Washington Post contains the first part of a three-part series on the mortgage crisis. Enclosed is the link.

Q&A with Phyllis Shelton

A standard feature of AViewfromDC will be a Q&A section on a variety of topics of importance to members of the housing and community development community. This week’s interview is with Phyllis Shelton. Phyllis is CEO of iPower Global Solutions. IGS is committed to empowering professionals and small business owners for success by mixing non-traditional venues, dynamic leaders and socially interactive activities in productive, yet relaxing environments. IGS insures companies succeed by implementing creative solutions through events, public relations and self empowerment opportunities. She has worked on 22 campaigns 21 of which have resulted in a victory for the candidate. Two of her more prominent clients were for New York City Mayor David N. Dinkins (the first African American Mayor in NY) and former first Lady and current Senator from New York, Hillary Rodham Clinton. She has received numerous awards for her and is a highly sought after political operative in New York City.

In this interview she discusses how to present your issues to a candidate running for office.

What must our audience do to meet with a candidate seeking elected office?

To see a candidate in a campaign you need to know someone or be considered fairly important so the candidate feels he/she must meet with you and address your issue of concern. Campaigns usually don’t respond to letters, they get inundated with a lot of letters. Also, the campaign staff, particularly the campaign manager, deputy campaign manager and secretary, tries to control the control everything that takes place with the candidate. You have to be someone of significant to get a meeting with the candidate. That means you have a large voting block or be an influential member of the community to be seen and heard. John Doe doesn’t have a chance to be seen. Phones are better entrees if you are a recognizable person or organization.

Does it make sense to hold an event, such as a town hall meeting, and invite the candidate to discuss issues?

Town hall meetings can work but it depends on the community and the environment. The higher the office sought, the less likely you will have the candidate attend. For example, you are more likely to have the candidate running for a local office like mayor attend a town hall meeting versus a person running for Congress or the President. In some cases, if you can guarantee a large, fairly receptive audience, of 200-300 participants, you might be successful in securing a visit from the candidate or a substitute. Oftentimes the invitation is declined due to “scheduling conflicts”. The candidate not attending happens all the time, the fall out is people develop a low level of expectation from their elected officials and may not vote. A substitute is more than enough if you want to hear where the candidate stands.

What type of event works best in getting the candidate to attend?

It is better to hold smaller events. In New York we hold coffee clutches where we invite a small group of people to meet with the candidate over coffee and pastries. If you can get a group up to approximately 50-60 influential people in your field, you can get the candidate to attend of a high-level surrogate who can be the entrée to a meeting with the candidate. For housing and community development professionals, these individuals may include the agency board members, the mayor, city or county council representatives, business owners, landlords and residents.

What should guide a voter’s thinking during this election season?

It is critical to look at the issues which are important to you when considering a candidate. When looking at those issues pick the candidate who will best address those issues regardless of political affiliation. There are good Republicans and bad Democrats and vice versa but there needs to be watchdogs in both parties to ensure certain issues are addressed. If a person votes simply on party affiliation, where are the checks and balances? Many people vote simply on emotion and that could be counterproductive to the issues of concern to the voter.

 
Design by Wordpress Theme | Bloggerized by Free Blogger Templates | JCPenney Coupons